A Sort of Sea-Feeling: On Being the Writer-in-Residence at Herman Melville’s Arrowhead

Entrance to Arrowhead the Herman Melville estate in Pittsfield Massachusetts
This is one of my favorite shots of Arrowhead. I caught it while on the drive out one day.

I am not easily “whelmed,” let alone overwhelmed. As a lifelong Northeasterner and an international traveler since the age of eight, hard-headedness and enough curiosity to kill an entire colony of cats are baked into my DNA. So while I was excited by the prospect of being the summer 2020 Writer-in-Residence at Arrowhead, the historic home of Herman Melville, and the program’s first travel writer, I was certain that working in Herman’s office would feel pretty much like any other work-at-home-day—which is most days for me.

  • Portrait of Herman Melville from Arrowhead in Pittsfield Massachusetts
  • Arrowhead 2020 writer in residence Robin Catalano in Herman Mevlille's study
  • Replica of a letter written by Herman Melville

But once I sat in Herman’s study, looking out at the same view of Mount Greylock that is reputed to have inspired Moby-Dick, I felt an inexplicable connection. To a man who, like his most famous narrator, was “tormented with an everlasting itch for things remote.” To a writer who often struggled with the reality of working in a profession where rejection is more common than publication. To a giant of American literature who used this landscape as a comfort and as a muse, and once wrote to a friend:

“I have a sort of sea-feeling here in the country now that the ground is covered in snow. I look out my window in the morning when I rise as I would out of a port-hole of a ship in the Atlantic. My room seems a ship’s cabin; & at nights when I wake up & hear the wind shrieking, I almost fancy there is too much sail on the house, & I had better go on the roof & rig in the chimney.”

The view of Mount Greylock that reputedly inspired Herman Melville's Moby-Dick
Here’s the famous view out Melville’s study window. I shot this on a cloudy day, but those faint gray humps above the treeline are Mount Greylock, the silhouette of which is reputed to have inspired Moby-Dick.

My time at Herman Melville’s Arrowhead was like a voyage on this ship. Even on days when the words didn’t flow as freely, I still had the sense that I was going somewhere, learning something new, becoming better at my craft. The residency afforded me the unfettered creative time writers so often lack, as we spend hours creating pitches, sending them to publications, and dealing with the inevitable follow-ups and rejection. For the first time since I was on college summer breaks, I had nowhere to be and nothing to do but write.

  • Fireplace at Arrowhead the Herman Melville historic house
  • Fireplace detail at Arrowhead, with the words to Herman Melville's "I and My Chimney"
  • Detail of the inscribed fireplace surround at Arrowhead, the Herman Melville house

As is often case for a writer—or an artist or craftsperson of any sort—I created a bunch of work during the residency, some of it not worth revisiting, and some of it I’m still shaping into pieces fit for public view. The cornerstone of my work there was “The Sea Is Calm Tonight,” a long-form travel story about revisiting my home state of Rhode Island. It turned out to be one of my proudest achievements, the kind of work that I feel such a deep connection with that if I never had the opportunity to write again, I’d still feel satisfied.

I’m in the process of submitting this story for publication. Travel publishing, like the rest of the tourism industry, has been knocked on its rear by the pandemic, and placing stories has been a challenge this year. I’ll keep you posted on its progress.  

Exterior view of Arrowhead, the historic home of Herman Melville in Pittsfield Massachusetts
The exterior of Arrowhead. The grounds here are beautiful, and worth visiting just for a walk among their fields and trails.

And as I keep refining old work and creating new stories, I’ll keep Herman’s indelible spirit of adventure with me.

Like what you see? Share it!